Trade proposal closers for (Hellickson or Beachy)

[joeyg2323]

I wouldn't do any of 3 closers for Hellickson.
To be honest, i wouldn't trade any of those 3 closers for Beachy, and i like Beachy.

you wouldnt trade walden for beachy? walden had the most BS last year i think.

[HOOTIE]

I wouldn't do any of 3 closers for Hellickson.
To be honest, i wouldn't trade any of those 3 closers for Beachy, and i like Beachy.

hootie apparently values closers wayyyy more than I do.

Brandon beachy is a top 20 pitcher. So, I guess you have to look at your strategy and decide whether a closer is more valuable than at top 20 SP. I personally wouldn't think about drafting a closer until about 50 SPs are off the board, so the choice is obvious to me.

Where they are drafted really has no bearing.
I like good closers, and those 3 are top 10-12.
I like Beachy a lot, probably around 25th SP to me, but SP is the easiest thing to find imo.
If it was a bad closer, i take Beachy.