Pick 3

[Element]

I have some DL/ML moves to make. I need to pick up 3 SP (Bauer, Carpenter & Fister to DL or ML). I cannot drop the replacements without using one of my 10 add/drop moves until one of my 'fulltime' players returns to the active 25 man roster. So 2 of these three moves need to stick for potentially 2+ months. Also, there is not a bench. All starts count. I've trimmed my options down to:

Billingsley
Samardjiza
Nicasio
Lynn

I'm leaning toward the top 3. Thoughts?

[ATLbraves]

The no doubt pick is Billingsley.

The other three are pretty speculative, but I would personally go with Samardjiza and Lynn. I just dont like that Nicasio has to pitch in Colorado. Carpenter will be out for awhile so Lynn will be in the rotation for a couple months at least.




help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=443889&p=3503950#p3503950

[lane_anasazi2]

The no doubt pick is Billingsley.

The other three are pretty speculative, but I would personally go with Samardjiza and Lynn. I just dont like that Nicasio has to pitch in Colorado.

I agree with this. Bills and Saamazijsdlkjsad;lfkj for sure. I'd probably go Lynn for the 3rd, but could easily be talked into The Casio Keyboard. Before that terrifying injury he was not having a problem with Coors, and I think his pure stuff is better than Lynn's.

[MaudDib]

I think I take Nicasio, Samardjiza and Lynn. Billingsley has been pretty bad and too many question marks for me to pick him up just yet. Lynn is a solid pickup because you have Carpenter and as long as Carpenter is out, Lynn should start. Then when Carpenter comes back, you can drop him without using one of your add/drops.

[HOOTIE]

Lynn is 4th

[bodsquad]

I don't think their is a big difference. I like the logic with Lynn though. I tend to lean towards who will produce the most K's.

[mixmastamikal]

The no doubt pick is Billingsley.

The other three are pretty speculative, but I would personally go with Samardjiza and Lynn. I just dont like that Nicasio has to pitch in Colorado.

I agree with this. Bills and Saamazijsdlkjsad;lfkj for sure. I'd probably go Lynn for the 3rd, but could easily be talked into The Casio Keyboard. Before that terrifying injury he was not having a problem with Coors, and I think his pure stuff is better than Lynn's.

Pretty much agree with this Lynn I believe is the higher risk higher reward guy. He is more likely to have a ten k game but also more likely to give up back HR.