Please help! Use #1 WW for Marmol? WHIR

[chinch sacs]

12 team 5x5 money league:

C- Mauer
1B- Youk
2B- Cano
3B- D. Wright
SS- Alexi Ramirez
OF- CarGo
OF- D. Jennings
OF- Hart
UT- Ryan Roberts
UT- D. Gordon
B- J. Montero
B- Morneau
B- Boesch

SP- C. Hamels
SP- D. Price
RP- Paps
RP- Street
P- Aceves
P- K. Jensen
P- M. Moore
P- Venters
B- C. Luebke
B- B. Norris
DL- T. Hudson

[MaudDib]

I wouldn't. Not real sure Marmol is a very solid RP. Keep #1 for something better.

[KaPluie]

Yeah! No reason for Marmol to be on the WW in a 12-team league.

[baegames]

Depends on one question. Are there any other closers in the Free Agent pile. If so, then pass. If not, maybe drop Bud Norris.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=443666&start=10

[chinch sacs]

Depends on one question. Are there any other closers in the Free Agent pile. If so, then pass. If not, maybe drop Bud Norris.

Next closest thing to "closers" on the WW are J. Peralta and M. Melancon

[baegames]

Use the #1 WW claim then.

[11stever11]

I would use the #1 for a better option

[lane_anasazi2]

I wouldn't. Not real sure Marmol is a very solid RP. Keep #1 for something better.

I don't think he's solid in terms of what you get day to day, but he does have job security and a history of putting up 10+ K/9. Wood isn't exactly knocking on the door and he'd have to blow quite a few more saves before Dollis got a chance. In a 12 team league I'm not sure a better player hits the wire all season. Of course if this is a Yahoo public league or something with similarly stupid/reactionary managers...

[MaudDib]

I wouldn't. Not real sure Marmol is a very solid RP. Keep #1 for something better.

I don't think he's solid in terms of what you get day to day, but he does have job security and a history of putting up 10+ K/9. Wood isn't exactly knocking on the door and he'd have to blow quite a few more saves before Dollis got a chance. In a 12 team league I'm not sure a better player hits the wire all season. Of course if this is a Yahoo public league or something with similarly stupid/reactionary managers...

Possibly nothing better will hit the WW but he has enough closers and I don't see anyone worth dropping. I just don't see that this will improve his team.

[HOOTIE]

I would use the #1 for a better option

I doubt there will that many better options, unless the league is full of clowns.
Marmol is a top 15 closer.