CarGo/Lohse/Cain for Fielder/Cuddyer/Masterson - Fair Offer?

[mm92280]

I am looking to flip Carlos Gonzalez in a trade for a power-hitting 1st baseman and an upgrade at SP and have thought about offering up my trio of Carlos Gonzales, Kyle Lohse and Lorenzo Cain for the trio of Prince Fielder, Michael Cuddyer, and Justin Masterson. Obviously, Fielder would easily fit the bill, as he is one of the top 1st baseman in fantasy baseball. Cuddyer could be an underrated guy, as I could see him hitting .280 with 28hr and around 90 RBI in Colorado and I do believe Masterson would be an upgrade over Lohse. Am I pushing for too much with this initial offer? I kind of thought I might be, as I know there are some owners out there that would value Fielder more than Gonzalez. BTW, this is a 20 team H2H keeper league (cats for the league are listed below). What do you guys think?

Just an FYI on scoring, we count: AVG, R, HR, RBI, SB, OPS, Assists ; for pitching: W, ERA, WHIP, K, CG, SV, Holds

Here is my lineup, as it now stands:

C: Carlos Santana (C,1B)
1B: Adam Dunn (1B, DH)
2B: B. Zobrist (2B, RF)
3B: K. Youkilis (3B)
SS: Y. Escobar (SS)
LF: A. Gordon (LF)
CF: Y. Cespedes (CF)
RF: C. Gonalez (RF, LF, CF)
Util: B. Boesch (RF, LF)
Util: L. Cain (RF)
Bn: W. Betemit (3B)
Bn: B. Ryan (SS)

SP: C. Hamels
SP: G. Gonzalez
SP: J. Garcia
SP: K. Lohse
SP: E. Volquez
SP: AJ Burnett
RP: D. Storen
RP: M. Melancon
RP: B. Fuentes
RP: J. Peralta

Thanks!

[onitapgr]

It's not a horrible offer...no harm in trying. I'd reject it though