luebke vs Beachy

[m3tsr0ck]

hey guys,
I am in a 12 team head to head league my current pitching staff is -
starsburg-beachy-billingsly- john niece, fister (DL) holland- melancon (getting dropped) sergio santos and street

I got rocked the first week - my offense is decent but my pitching is weak with the only solid pitcher on my staff being starsburg - I really like beachy this year but he did get rocked in the spring and vance was pretty good last year thoughts on this deal

i give up - Beachy
I get - Vance Worley and Luebke

thanks

[lastingsgriller]

I personally rank luebke and beachy right next to each other. I think they are pretty equal. I would say try to get luebke without giving up beachy. But if that's not possible, I'd take the deal offered.

[kidsilk]

I like Beachy a bit more than Leubke but that might be in the minority. Like Lastings said if you can get Leubke to go beside Beachy instead of giving him up I would definitely do it. As it stands right now I would probably keep Beachy.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=443680

[mixmastamikal]

To me Worley is pretty much a non factor in this trade, he really is only worth starting in certain situations. That being said I like Beachy more than Luebke, but not by a whole lot. Both are very talented young pitchers, it sucks for luebke that he is on one of the best teams to pitch against in the division and won't see a ton of run support. Beachy gets better match ups more regularly and has more chances at W's. K rates, walk rates should be similar (and good for that matter).

[MaudDib]

I would rather have Beachy.

[joeyg2323]

i go with Beachy. both high K pitchers but with beachy on the better team pushes him ahead. personal i think beachy is better.



viewtopic.php?f=26&t=443721

[lastingsgriller]

While beachy may have the wins potential, luebke has park factor which protects his era & whip. High k/9 + petco = last years sexy 1.07 whip.

[bigh0rt]

Given that by the time the H2H Playoffs roll around, Strasburg may be skipping starts or shut down completely, and a small possibility of the same happening with Beachy, I'm actually leaning to the Luebke and Worley side of this. I think more highly of Worley than most, though, and think he's gonna have a pretty good season.

[HOOTIE]

I would rather have Beachy.

[joeyg2323]

Given that by the time the H2H Playoffs roll around, Strasburg may be skipping starts or shut down completely, and a small possibility of the same happening with Beachy, I'm actually leaning to the Luebke and Worley side of this. I think more highly of Worley than most, though, and think he's gonna have a pretty good season.

beachy wont get shut down at all