Trade Help WHIR

[friedrich15]

14 team keeper 5x5 i give up Belt and revieve Kipnis...i wanted Kipnis and missed out on him in the draft and ended up with kelly johnson ....now i have a chance to get him for Belt..what do you guys think is he an upgrade over johnson and as a possible keeper ...thanks guys

Soto
Votto
K Johnson
Reyes
Wright
Kemp
Stubbs
Heyward
Tabata
Belt
M. Aviles

Bumgarner
CJ Wilson
Max Sherzer
Ervin Santana
Billinglsey
Danks
Volquez
Holland
Jarrod Parker
Walden
R. Betancourt
Clippard

[jefferey13]

Ya it's a good trade, but I think ending up shorter in the OF and having Johnson around doesn't help. I would try to get Johnson into the package so you can replace belt somehow.

[MaudDib]

I think it is a good deal. Belt and Kipnis both could turn into keepers but both still have to prove it. And yes i like kipnis pretty easily of KJ.

[mpieco]

I love Belt, but Kipnis is a great player as well. Depends on keeper settings a bit too, but I wouldn't say this is a bad deal.

[friedrich15]

top

[HOOTIE]

Depends on how many you keep?
But i think Belt is the better player.

[Seanyfever]

I think Belt carries a litlte more value, but not enough to bicker on. This makes sense in your situaiton.