2 Trade Offers on the Table WHIR

[germani40]

Probably should point out we can keep up to 16 guys for as long as we want with no penalty


Offer A
I get
Hellickson
Dom Brown
Wil Myers
Alex Gordon


I Give
Matt Moore

I would probably drop Billingsley and Drew and I would put Utley on the DL

Offer B
I get
Dom Brown
Wil Myers
David Price

I Give
Hosmer

Should I do either one of these?

[jefferey13]

A is a steal. Click accept ASAP

[jovenparque]

i agree with the poster above. accept trade a.

[soupy56]

A is a steal. Click accept ASAP

I'm with this guy.

Please help: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=443206

[Seanyfever]

Deal A. Moorse is studly, but you are raking in the first deal.


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=443216

[mpieco]

Deal A is very good. One prospect for 4? They all have equal chances of becoming studs, so why not?

[BigLebowski]

It's a bit harder without seeing your roster and current keepers. In a vacuum I don't do either deal. But if you have very few good keepers then maybe I'd pull the trigger.

[germani40]

It's a bit harder without seeing your roster and current keepers. In a vacuum I don't do either deal. But if you have very few good keepers then maybe I'd pull the trigger.

My roster is in my signature. 12 teams and we keep 16

[silverZ]

Offer A
I get
Hellickson
Dom Brown
Wil Myers
Alex Gordon

I Give
Matt Moore

I would probably take this because I'm high on Myers. Gordon and Hellboy will give you enough value to make this a push for this year. Add in Myers and Brown's upside next year and it's worth taking. With that said, I would still shop Moore around a little bit. You MIGHT be able to get a better deal if you think Gordon and Hellboy will regress this year.

[germani40]

Offer A
I get
Hellickson
Dom Brown
Wil Myers
Alex Gordon

I Give
Matt Moore

I would probably take this because I'm high on Myers. Gordon and Hellboy will give you enough value to make this a push for this year. Add in Myers and Brown's upside next year and it's worth taking. With that said, I would still shop Moore around a little bit. You MIGHT be able to get a better deal if you think Gordon and Hellboy will regress this year.

I was thinking about trying to swap out Hellickson and get Price