j upton/cj wilson/scutaro for reyes/mccutchen?

[mjb412]

standard yahoo scoring roto league
my team:
c- mccann
1b- pujols
2- pedroia
3- david wright
ss- marco scutaro
of- justin upton, granderson, jay bruce
util- austin jackson, mark reynolds
bench- angel pagan, kelly johnson, morneau, aviles
sp- cj wilson, max scherzer
rp- jose valverde, brian wilson
p- shaun marcum, ted lilly, aroldis chapman, chris carpenter, bud norris

should i propose this trade?

[lbblue]

Hmmm...I don't think I make that move. Reyes would look a lot nicer in your SS position than Scutaro, obviously, not at the price of CJ Wilson from your SP and a downgrade at OF (not a huge downgrade there, but a bit of one, IMO).

[Leiter Fan]

Hmmm...I don't think I make that move. Reyes would look a lot nicer in your SS position than Scutaro, obviously, not at the price of CJ Wilson from your SP and a downgrade at OF (not a huge downgrade there, but a bit of one, IMO).

I agree. Maybe swap Scherzer for CJ Wilson as the pitcher you will give up.

[mjb412]

i proposed granderson/marcum/scutaro for reyes/mccutchen. i think it tilts in my favor a lot but it's a good place to start and if he rejects i'll offer a little more. should i offer upton over granderson or wilson over marcum first?

[Leiter Fan]

i proposed granderson/marcum/scutaro for reyes/mccutchen. i think it tilts in my favor a lot but it's a good place to start and if he rejects i'll offer a little more. should i offer upton over granderson or wilson over marcum first?

IMO, your pitching behind CJ has a ton of question marks, so I would not include CJ no matter what.