Final Keeper - C. Santana or Hamilton?

[Drederick13]

Standard 5x5, 12 team league. We do play 4 OFs as well

Who would you pick as a keeper?

[jefferey13]

Given no other information I would pick Hamilton.

[Pogotheostrich]

Hamilton

[Drederick13]

Sorry I tried to keep it brief.. lets see we keep 5 guys my other 4 right now are Miggy, Pujols, Hosmer, and King Felix

Start C,1b,2b,3b,SS,4 OF, 2 UTL for offense
4 SP, 2 RP, 1 UTL for pitching

Head to Head league with 5X5 scoring, 12 teams

hope this helps!

[HOOTIE]

Hamilton

[Drederick13]

Hamilton it is, thanks y'all!

[HOOTIE]

I know most would disagree, but i keep Hamilton and Santana, over Hosmer.
Santana is the best keeper C.
I like Hosmer, but he's easier to replace then a Santana.
And Hamilton is just too good to go Hosmer/Santana.

[exm]

I know most would disagree, but i keep Hamilton and Santana, over Hosmer.
Santana is the best keeper C.
I like Hosmer, but he's easier to replace then a Santana.
And Hamilton is just too good to go Hosmer/Santana.

I would keep Hosmer and Santana. Don't drop Hosmer. He'll be a top 10 player in 2013, guaranteed. Hamilton is great with a lot of question marks.

[HOOTIE]

I know most would disagree, but i keep Hamilton and Santana, over Hosmer.
Santana is the best keeper C.
I like Hosmer, but he's easier to replace then a Santana.
And Hamilton is just too good to go Hosmer/Santana.

I would keep Hosmer and Santana. Don't drop Hosmer. He'll be a top 10 player in 2013, guaranteed. Hamilton is great with a lot of question marks.

I like Hosmer, but top 10 is quite a stretch?

[Fenris-77]

Hamilton over Santana. Hosmer vs Santana is a coin flip at best IMO, and only because of Santana's C eligibility. Picking out of the three, I think I'd keep Hamilton and Hosmer (mostly because Santana doesn't excite me much in a 1C league)