John Mayberry or Eric Thames

[jlm53089]

Both are available in my 5X5 ROTO league, add OBP.

I was wondering who is the better pick up in your opinion.
Thanks

[jefferey13]

I would take Mayberry, slightly better numbers all around and more experience.

[MaudDib]

I would take Mayberry as well. He also has less to contend with him if he struggles. If Thames struggles then Snider could be called up.

[Quackman]

Mayberry,,,grab him fast. Dble his stats of last year and thats what your going to get. Way undervalued especially with Howard out maybe till june or later. Even when howard comes back, i think they will find a spot for mayberry. Huge guy,,,big power upside and hes in his prime in terms of age. gl

[Benkei]

I would take Mayberry as well. He also has less to contend with him if he struggles. If Thames struggles then Snider could be called up.

Is Dominic Brown written off altogether now???

[MaudDib]

I would take Mayberry as well. He also has less to contend with him if he struggles. If Thames struggles then Snider could be called up.

Is Dominic Brown written off altogether now???

No. Mayberry will be covering more for Ryan Howard and who knows when he will be ready to come back.