Which pitcher to pickup...[AWHIR]

[TruYankeeFan]

My point from before is you are presenting other peoples opinions to us and then saying pick one. You don't need us for that, you are already basing your choice on what someone else is predicting. Just pick the one that gives you the most points or PR or whatever for your league. As you can see your first set of numbers and second set don't match up at all.

If you want our opinions, tell us which guys you are considering and we can tell you what we think.

Ironic then that the same guy gets the nod from ZIPS...

F with 8.34k/9

ps...I do appreciate the help and am not trying to be difficult. I just wanted to run this exercise this way anyway...as I really do believe it has value for me.

who is who:
Pitcher A: Dempster
Pitcher B: Floyd
Pitcher C: Dickey
Pitcher D: Niese
Pitcher E: Buehrle
Pitcher F: J Sanchez

[HOOTIE]

Sanchez walks too many, he's a whip killer.
I like Dempster/Niese
I don't agree on Dempsters era being that high.

[Anicholsnj]

F does look like the best choice but I would also like to see some names.... I understand leaving them off and why you did that. At this point you should reveal names so we can further converse.

[TruYankeeFan]

F does look like the best choice but I would also like to see some names.... I understand leaving them off and why you did that. At this point you should reveal names so we can further converse.

Look two posts up

[footballisbetter.com]

Before I saw the names, I was thinking F also. But now that I see the names, I would take Dempster all day. I see his ERA going down from last year.

see mine viewtopic.php?t=442709