Selling high on Jacoby - Dynasty League - WHIR!

[zephyr]

OK...I just made a deal for Matt Kemp as my CF so, Jacoby's "available". It's a first-year dynasty league...6x6 (K's).

I think Jacoby comes crashing down to earth this year. And if I trade him...I sure hope he does. I think the SB's will remain but there's no way he repeats the power is there? I mean, 3-times as many HR's last year as any year before. Unless he's the second-coming of Bautista, I guess.

Anyway...I'm very willing to move him in the right deal.

Here's some potential deals that are being "discussed":

His: Cano/BJ Upton - FOR - My: Jacoby/Kelly Jonshon
His: Lawrie/Kipinis/Fowler - FOR - My: Jacoby/K. Johnson/M. Izturis (though, I'm trying to work in Freeman for Carlos Lee/Chad Billingsley too).
His: CarGo and change - FOR - My: Jacoby and change

The Lawrie/Kipinis/Fowler offer is the only one that's "on the table" waiting for me to accept.

Open to any other ideas. What should Jacoby's value be in my 6x6 dynasty?!

THANKS!!

[kidsilk]

I'm actually a believer in Jacoby....I think he continues to be a stud and I value him a slight bit higher than CarGo but not by much. If you want to switch from Ells to CarGO I wouldn't blame you but I just look at it as a lateral trade. I really like the Cano deal and the Lawrie one is ok but I probably wouldn't do it.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=442505

[jefferey13]

I don't see Ellsbury "crashing." But I do agree with above poster that the Cano deal is a good one.

[joeyg2323]

i would take the cano deal in a heartbeat. cano is a top 5 hitter in the league and upton is a potential 20/20 player



viewtopic.php?f=26&t=442652&p=3495037#p3495037

[ggs]

id def take the cano deal, and think hard to see if i can rework the lawrie deal slightly.

[MaudDib]

I like 1 and 3. 3 depends on what that change is but I think I might like it the most although it also depends on what your roster looks like. I am not a big Upton fan and if you count K's for hitters then it is another knock against him.