Keeper Trade WHIR

[germani40]

I usually dont try to get more than 2 closers on a team but I dont really have anyone who is sure at his spot (Guerra/Johnson/Myers)
If he wants to do Ramirez or Billingsley for Marshall straight up should I do that?

I give
Alexei Ramirez
Chad Billingsley

I Get
Sean Marshall
Chris Young

[Nighttrain]

I would do the trade only because I view Billingsley as useless. Basically you get Young and Marshall for Alexi.

Help on mine
viewtopic.php?t=442521

[chump dumper]

I think I would pull the trigger on that one.
Your SP looks good and you can afford to get rid of Billingsly....who won't do much anyway.
Young is going to have a decent year.....and Marshall should be great.

[Element]

I'm guessing that you're drafting this offer for another owner. If I were the other owner I wouldn't consider giving up Chris Young for those two guys combined. I'm certainly not going to toss in Marshall. If the block head accepts it kudos to you. I doubt that you'd get a counter offer though.

[AmazinSiddFinch]

I'd do it. You have plenty of pitching and I like Peralta more than Ramirez anyway. Big upgrade at OF plus another closer. Do it to it.

Help me?
viewtopic.php?t=442552

[germani40]

Should I do Alexei for Marshall straight up

[HOOTIE]

Should I do Alexei for Marshall straight up

I wouldn't.
I like him the best of your 3 SS, and Marshall is good, but i hear Baker is worried about him pitching 3 days in a row.