Having a hard time on my last keeper(s)... help? WHIR!

[spike095]

12 team Y! 5x5 H2H -- can keep previous keepers year-to-year.

Need to select 5 keepers. I narrowed it down to:
*C. Santana
*Posey
Gardner
Rasmus
*Kershaw
*Weaver
Kimbrel
Kennedy
*Latos

with * players the ones I'm leaning toward. Have multiple trains of thought for the last two after selecting Kershaw, Weaver & Santana as my first three:
-Keep Latos or Kennedy (leaning more toward Latos due to Kennedy's luck factor) as my 3rd SP to lock down most pitching categories?
-Keep Posey for a bounce-back year or tradebait?
-Keep Kimbrel (I hate keeping closers though... even if he is the consensus #1 and young)?
-Keep another batter (Gardner most likely)?

Any ideas on what the proper course of action is here? Thanks in advance, and WHIR.

[Nighttrain]

I'd keep
Santana
Posey
Kershaw
Weaver
Kennedy

Obvious you need to go heavy hitting early and I'd trade Santana or posey ASAP.

viewtopic.php?t=442521

[HOOTIE]

Santana
Posey
Kershaw
Weaver
Latos

[kaiser]

Yu've answered your own question. Take the five you starred.