Final Keeper: Matt Moore or Jordan Zimmerman

[MrT]

Must report kepers in morning!
Down to Moore at $10 or Zimmerman at $10. They can be kept only for this year. 12 team 5 x5 auction roto league 9 pitchers 14 hitters all play, no reserves.

Same price so who is better for 2012?

[kidsilk]

I'd go with Moore even though you can only keep him for a year.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=442505

[HOOTIE]

I like both, but might lean Moore.

[TruYankeeFan]

I like Moore...kid is just nasty, and should do work this year.

Any thoughts on mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=442477

[MaudDib]

I am going to say Zimmermann. I really like both of them but honestly very few rookie's actually put up the year we think they will. Zimmermann is the safest option and has some pretty good upside as well.

[Nighttrain]

MOORE HANDS DOWN. Hope you made right choice.

Help on mine
viewtopic.php?t=442521

[Element]

I like both, but might lean Moore.

This. I love Zimmermann too and agree with Maud to a certain extent, but for only $10 I'll gamble.

[AmazinSiddFinch]

I am going to say Zimmermann. I really like both of them but honestly very few rookie's actually put up the year we think they will. Zimmermann is the safest option and has some pretty good upside as well.

I'm with him. I love me some Jordo.

Help me?
viewtopic.php?t=442552

[Nighttrain]

When Zimmerman gets his K rate above 7 lets talk. Right now he's one of the most over rated SPs. Does not compare to Moore.

[Tex34]

I am going to say Zimmermann. I really like both of them but honestly very few rookie's actually put up the year we think they will. Zimmermann is the safest option and has some pretty good upside as well.

BINGO! If you need proof, look up Price and Kershaw's rookie seasons. Moore almost certainly will win around 10 games with an ERA over 4.00. He's only worth drooling over in keeper leagues.

Zimmerman, on the other hand, has the innings and surgery out of the way and is primed to breakout.