Is this trade fair?

[HOOTIE]

ZIPS or MARCEL are decent imo, but to each his own.
ZIPS has Crisp at 31, Marcel at 38.
ZIPS accounts for past history, including injuries.
In the last 6 years, Crisp has played 140 games once.
He gets hurt a lot.

[Coolfinity]

True, but even with injuries he's had his best two years in terms of SB have been his last two. 49 SB in 583 PA is damn impressive, and so is 32 SB in 328 PA. Hitting 3rd in Oakland's lineup should give him some decent RBI numbers as well. I don't think he'll be quite as good as Bourn, but comparable. .270 with 40 SB, 10 HRs and 65 RBI would be very realistic IMO.

[jtsandwich]

It's very close, I think it is almost a coin toss.