Longo for Holliday

[baseballfanTigers]

16 team keeper league 5 keepers

Jon Lester
Jaime Garcia
Matt Holliday
Melky Cabrera
Ryan Roberts
3rd


for

Longo
Sean Marshall
Ted Lilly
Angel Pagan
12th


My team:

C McCann
1B Freeman
2B Espinosa
3B Roberts
SS Dee Gordon
OF Stanton
OF Maybin
OF Holliday
UTL Edwin Encarnacion
UTL Melky Cabrera

SP Josh Johnson
SP Lester
SP Hellickson
SP Beachy
SP Jaime Garcia
SP Mark Buehrle
RP Jim Johnson
RP JJ Putz

[Halo Homers]

As much as it would be nice to have Longo and he's the best player in the trade, I would not do it.

It just guts your SP and OF too much, espeically since Josh Johnson is your #1 SP, you need Lester in case he goes to the DL.

Please help with my question. Here is the link.

viewtopic.php?t=442432

[MaudDib]

Agreed with above. Not a trade I like. While Longoria is the best player in the deal you are giving up 2 very good SP and the better pick. Not sure what you would really gain out of this trade.

[baseballfanTigers]

Is this better?

Holliday
Lester
Ryan Roberts
3rd
6th
8th

for

Longo
Pagan
Lilly
11th
14th
17th

[BigLebowski]

Nope.

Holliday and Lester and MISC is too much to give up for Longo.

[mikekim2121]

That second offer is better but that's still too much to give up. Pass