I would rank them as follows
1) Peavy - Could return to being a borderline #1. Saids he's heathly again.
2) Bedard - Ditto as Peavy except health is an issue. Probably looking at 100-150 IP.
3) Volquez - I could swap him and Bedard. More upside than Bedard, pitching in Petco, but it won't matter if he does not stop walking hitters.
4) Lilly - A decent option for throwing at home with the right matchup.
Please help with mine. viewtopic.php?t=442432