Is this a fair offer?? WHIR

[Jase44]

Keeper - 10 teams
Batting - R, 2B, HR, AVG, SB, BB, OPS,
My roster (not including BN)

C- Montero
1B - Hosmer
2B - Kinsler
SS - A Cabrera
3B - Ramirez
OF - Heyward
OF - Morse
OF - C.Young
OF - Bourn
Util - M.Reynolds

SP's - Price, Pineda, Jimenez, Moore, Carpenter, Luebke,
RP's - Axford, Santos, Holland

Guy I'm dealing with has a stacked OF (J.Upton, Braun & Kemp) but has next to no SP, thinking of offering the following:

Kinsler
Young OR Heyward
Moore

for

Phillips
J.Upton

PS - Lilly, W.Rodriguez, Lewis, Norris, Minor, Leake, Vogelsong, Niese are all available on the wire.

Think it's fair? Or am I giving up too much to to get Upton?

Thanks in advance

[Jase44]

Forgot to mention RBI as a cat and the Pitching is - W, K, ERA, WHIP, SV

[Wadderboiz]

Fair offer ... yes. Not sure I'd want to give up M. Moore but overall it's a fair offer.

[germani40]

Its a fair offer but I feel like you would get the worst of that deal. I usually dont say that when you end up getting the better player but youre giving up a great 2B, a potential Cy Young guy in a couple years, and a guy with amazing upside who had one down year. If anything try to swap in Pineda instead of Moore and I would do Heyward as my last offer in the deal. I would try every other outfielder and settle with giving up Heyward at the end


help viewtopic.php?f=26&t=442046

[Jase44]

If I do go ahead with it do you think getting N.Feilz back is worthwhile or would you rather have any of the SP off of the wire?

[Jase44]

Update:
Phillips
J.Upton
2013 4th round

for

Kinsler
C. Young
U. Jimenez
2013 2nd round

[HOOTIE]

In a keeper, i make this trade for sure. To get Upton.
Imo, i would lose Jimenez for Minor, and Norris is not bad.

[joeyg2323]

id do that last trade easy. upton is the best player of the deal and phillips isnt bad either. kinsler is a lil better then phillips but not by much, jiminez is a one year wonder and young your replacing big with upton. pick up minor and think this trade will really work out for you.


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=442384

[Jase44]

Thanks guys, doubt he'll accept but considering his weak pitching you never know. If not I'll throw in Pineda instead of Jimenez and see if he goes for it then.

[Jase44]

Sorry guys, been back and forth a bit

Going to offer:
Kinsler
Morse
I. Desmond
Jimenez
2nd pick

for

Phillips
J. Upton

Don't think I'm going to go more than that. He has asked for a backup SS and needs SP. I figure Desmond is easy to replace off of the wire as a BN player and I actually prefer a couple FA's over Jimenez.

Any thoughts?