12 Team Dynasty* Hamilton/Waiwright 4 Heyward/Weiters?

[Seatownfavorite]

12 Dynasty Roto league that uses every conceivable stat.

Would you trade:

Hamilton & Wainwright

4

Zobrist & (Heyward or Weiters)

My Team
C: Posey
1B: Pujols
2B: Kipnis
SS: Dee Gordon
3B: Hanley Ramirez
INF: Cozart
LF: Hamilton
CF: Gardner
RF: Cruz
OF: Bruce
Util: Alex Gordon
BN: Trout, Belt, Parra, Chris Davis, Lorenzo Cain, Lavarnaway, Rendon

SP: Hernandez
SP: Hamels
SP: Linececum
SP: Wainwright
RP: Madson
RP: Adams
P: Jansen
P: Venters
P: Greg Holland
BN: Moore, Beachy, Derek Holland

I'm leaning towards no but I could definitely use the inf help.

[SecretAgentMan]

No, definitely not.

I like Zobrist, but not enough to trade Hamilton and Wainwright for him. And I do not like Heyward and you do not need Wieters. I would not trade Hamilton for Zobrist straight up, but at least that would be a lot better than this.

If you are worried about 2b, why not try to offer Beachy in some deal that nets you someone like Phillips or maybe even an Uggla depending on the offer.

[MadDog36]

I'd take Heyward and Zobrist. You have the room to take a downgrade to the slightest in your rotation. Heywrad can slot at OF and you can move Bruce to LF you should be able to anyway. The only hole on your team is 2b and Zobrist gives you that nicely. Value wise straight up yes you don't win BUT for your TEAM NEEDS? Yes.

[MaudDib]

No. Not sure I would do the deal for just Hamilton let alone throwing in Wainwright as well. Remember Hamilton can be a top 10 player if he is on. He is unlikely to stay healthy all year but that usually won't hurt his numbers all that much. Wainwright can be a top 5 SP. I need more than a questionable Heyward and a good Zobrist.

[Seatownfavorite]

So some differing opinions. We have gone back and forth and here is his offer now...

Hamilton/Wainwright
4
Weiters/Heyward

Obviously this carries a lot of risk, but in a Dynasty getting two young talents is always going to be a gamble. 3 years from now we could look back and see this go either way. The only thing really holding me back is I think I have the best team this season and I don't believe this is necessary or an improvement this year. I do believe this will be a win for me 5 years from now.

Thoughts?