Should I accept this trade?!!?

[TheGhost]

12 teams, yahoo, redraft, roto, 5x5, H2H...

I was just offered this trade...

My: Matt Cain and Robinson Cano
for
His: Desmond Jennings and Dustin Pedroia

I'm inclined to turn this down unless somebody here can persuade me to do otherwise. Would love to hear some counteroffer ideas that would help tip this deal in my favor. I posted our rosters below. THANKS!

My Team:
C: Buster Posey
1B: Mike Napoli
2B: Robinson Cano
3B: Pablo Sandoval
SS: Asdrubal Cabrera
OF: Yoenis Cespedes
OF: Martin Prado
OF: Kendrys Morales
UTL: Ike Davis
Bench: Dexter Folwer, Alejandro De Aza

SP: Cliff Lee
SP: Justin Verlander
RP: Mariano Rivera
RP: Chris Perez
P: Matt Cain
P: Matt Garza
P: Ubaldo Jimenez
Bench: Clay Bucholz, Scott Baker, Jair Jurrjens

His Team:
C: Matt WEiters
1B: Albert Pujols
2B: Dustin Pedroia
3B: David Wright
SS: Jimmy Rollins
OF: Desmond Jennings
OF: Michael Bourn
OF: Shin Soo Choo
UTL: Chris Young
Bench: Austin Jackson, Alexei Ramirez, Delmon Young, Edwin Encarnacion, Ryan Doumit

SP: Michael Pineda
SP: Jordan Zimmerman
RP: Sergio santos
RP: Addison Reed
P: Jeremy Hellickson
P: Tim Hudson
P: Mike Leake

[jefferey13]

Bad trade.

For you to win I would think instead of getting jennings you get bourn. But, I don't think he would go for that. Your team is already twice as good as his. I think you would still win for your situation if you did

Lee + Cano
for
Bourn + Pedroia + Jennings

[footballisbetter.com]

I don't really like this trade. However you might want to look for another deal. I think you could use an upgrade in the outfield, and your pitching looks strong.

[jruffus1]

I think that this is a GREAT trade for you. Your team is severely lacking in the stolen base department, which both Jennings and Pedroia will help you with. I actually like Pedroia more than Cano straight up this season (and I am from NYC).

Bourn may be a stolen base machine, but Jennings stole 20 bases within the last 2 months of the season. Plus, Jennings has the kind of power that Bourn doesn't. PLUS the fact that your in a keeper league, and Jennings could very well be an up and coming star.

In other words, Jennings and Bourn are not even in the same hemisphere (IMO)

[HOOTIE]

I wouldn't do it as i like Cano over Pedroia, and Cain by quite a bit over Jennings.
I would look to move a C, since you have 2 in your lineup.
Jennings career high was 12 hrs in the minors.
He projects to 10-12.
You do need speed, but i'm not overpaying to get it.

[TheGhost]

I think that this is a GREAT trade for you. Your team is severely lacking in the stolen base department, which both Jennings and Pedroia will help you with. I actually like Pedroia more than Cano straight up this season (and I am from NYC).

Bourn may be a stolen base machine, but Jennings stole 20 bases within the last 2 months of the season. Plus, Jennings has the kind of power that Bourn doesn't. PLUS the fact that your in a keeper league, and Jennings could very well be an up and coming star.

In other words, Jennings and Bourn are not even in the same hemisphere (IMO)

You guys, I'm an idiot and confused the settings with another league. SORRY...

The real settings are: yahoo, 12 teams, roto, redraft, 5X5.... thanks. Any other thoughts considering the different settings??

[MaudDib]

I wouldn't do it as i like Cano over Pedroia, and Cain by quite a bit over Jennings.
I would look to move a C, since you have 2 in your lineup.
Jennings career high was 12 hrs in the minors.
He projects to 10-12.
You do need speed, but i'm not overpaying to get it.

I agree with this. I don't like Jennings this much. I need to see more from him before I am giving up a pitcher like Cain for him.

[TeeBall DH]

You lose this trade.

If you want to acquire Jennings and Pedrioa offer Cano and Jurrjens, although not sure they would accept that.

I say hang onto both Cano and Cain Honestly.

[Element]

You lose this trade.

If you want to acquire Jennings and Pedrioa offer Cano and Jurrjens, although not sure they would accept that.

I say hang onto both Cano and Cain Honestly.

yup