Complicated Keeper Question!(WHIR)

[MaudDib]

I would take both pitchers. Mauer and Trumbo have too many question marks add in that pitching is weighed more, I would rather take the risk on the guys that could help you win a title.

Nobody has more question marks then Jimenez, who has stunk for over a year.
Even the Indians are worried about his dip in velocity.
Trumbo at worst goes 20/70.

I guess I think Trumbo can do worse than 20/70 especially if playing time ever starts to be a problem (bad at 3B so has to split time at DH and 1B). While I agree Jimenez is awful, there is still upside there. His k rate and BB rate have stayed the same and he has been a little bit unlucky with BABIP. There are plenty of concerns like his fastball isn't as fast anymore. If he gets that fixed, he could turn things around.