Is this too much for Uggla? ALL HELP RETURNED

[kaiser]

Leave a link for returned help.

ten team H2H keeper.

I give Ben Zobrist and Madison Bumgarner.

I get Dan Uggla.

Is the upgrade from Zobrist to Uggla worth losing Bumgarner?

My roster:


10-team H2H keeper (keep 4)
Most cats (standard 5X5)

C Alex Avila, Det C
1B Miguel Cabrera, Det, 1B
2B Ben Zobrist, TB 2B, OF
3B Kevin Youkilis, Bos 3B
SS Hanley Ramirez, Mia SS
2B/SS Marco Scutaro, Col SS
1B/3B Joey Votto, Cin 1B
OF Jay Bruce, Cin OF
OF Shane Victorino, Phi OF
OF Brett Gardner, NYY OF
OF Cameron Maybin, SD OF
OF Raul Ibanez, NYY OF
UTIL Adam Dunn, CWS 1B, DH
P Zack Greinke, Mil SP
P Jeremy Hellickson, TB SP
P Madison Bumgarner, SF SP
P Jason Motte, StL RP
P Rafael Betancourt, Col RP
P Scott Baker, Min SP
P Ted Lilly, LAD SP
P Matt Thornton, CWS RP
P Brandon Morrow, Tor SP
Bench Brett Myers, Hou SP
Bench Vance Worley, Phi SP
Bench Jason Kubel, Ari OF, DH

[Element]

I don't even see Zobrist to Uggla as an upgrade.

[Lobo28561]

No way, thats way too much, id rather zobrist over uggla

[kaiser]

I understand what you are saying. I consider Zobrist almost as good as Uggla, but I trust Uggs more. Just thought I would see where others valued each of them.

[GiantsFan14]

I don't even see Zobrist to Uggla as an upgrade.

this. I wouldn't trade either of them straight up for uggla, both is just ridiculous.

[HOOTIE]

I understand what you are saying. I consider Zobrist almost as good as Uggla, but I trust Uggs more. Just thought I would see where others valued each of them.

Just wondering why you trust Uggla more?
His OPS last year was a career low.
I prefer Zobrist over him myself.

[kaiser]

Just wondering why you trust Uggla more?
His OPS last year was a career low.
I prefer Zobrist over him myself.

Just a gut feeling that that epic slump he suffered was an anomaly. I passed on Uggs at $26 and drafted Zobrist at $24 in our auction because I thought they were about equal. Maybe I'm just having a crisis of confidence.

Thanks for the input.

[jefferey13]

From this post and your other one about trades, I think you suffer from the grass is always greener complex.

[kaiser]

From this post and your other one about trades, I think you suffer from the grass is always greener complex.

Perhaps, but I think it is more that I'm just trying to take advantage of a new guy in our league who totally mangled the draft. To me, it looks like he doesn't know what he is doing (but thinks he does), and I'm trying to profit from that.

[silverZ]

I'd take Zobrist over Uggla, and I have a huge man crush on Bumgarner.

viewtopic.php?f=7&t=441843&p=3490068#p3490068