Need Help With Blockbuster... WHIR **UPDATED**

[ATLbraves]

*****UPDATED*****
The other owner got cold feet about the Carpenter injury situation and nixed the deal. HOWEVER... he says that if I include Beachy instead of Carp that he'll do the trade as is in the opening post. I'm hesitant to part with Beachy but I have a tendency to fall in love with my guys. Can you guys help me with this? Check out the opening post for the details. If you think I'm better off with Ethier or Crawford rather than Bourn then I can definitely get any one of those guys. I've bolded the updated details in the original post.

Thanks in advance and please leave a link if you need some advice.

I think even with giving up Beachy instead, it is a good deal for you. I would consider taking Ethier if you need HR's and RBI's more, if you need SB's obviously just stick with Bourn.

[germani40]

I woulda it. I'm a big fan of bourn and you get Pujols too. Good deal

[mpieco]

*****UPDATED*****
The other owner got cold feet about the Carpenter injury situation and nixed the deal. HOWEVER... he says that if I include Beachy instead of Carp that he'll do the trade as is in the opening post. I'm hesitant to part with Beachy but I have a tendency to fall in love with my guys. Can you guys help me with this? Check out the opening post for the details. If you think I'm better off with Ethier or Crawford rather than Bourn then I can definitely get any one of those guys. I've bolded the updated details in the original post.

Thanks in advance and please leave a link if you need some advice.

Bourn infinitely better than Andre Ethier (who is an overrated turd) and Carl Crawford when healthy is better than Bourn, but I'm not too positive about his health. I'd stick with Bourn in that deal.

If he wants someone as good as Beachy in the deal, then you need to be getting back a better closer or better SP, because I like the deal much less if you have to give up Beachy.