kershaw (3) or cuddyer (15) keeper

[footballisbetter.com]

I'm a Cuddyer guy, and I'd still go Kershaw here.

[MaudDib]

Yup take Kershaw, I think that sometimes there is too much concentration on getting a good value. If you do that for your whole team your team won't be that good. Sometimes you just need get the best to be the best. I hate the yankees, but man they have a lot of rings.

I agree with this. Maybe Cuddyer is worth more than a 15 but he is what he is. Nothing special and no upside. Kershaw has the ability to win a you a title and keeping Cuddyer at 15 isn't going to do that.