Moustakas or Goldschmidt? Convince me.

[Rotowahoo]

Okay, so who would you keep? Moustakas or Goldschmidt? As of right now, I feel like Goldschmidt may suffer, while Moustakas might settle in like he has in the minors. Obviously, I could use a 3B more than 1B, but I'm flexible. Who will have the better 2012? Better 2013?

Roto, 10 owners, 15-offensive, 10-pitchers, $280 max, 5-10 keepers

C - C.Santana, $5 (+$10 for long-term contract)
C -
1B - E.Hosmer, $5
3B
CI
2B
SS - S.Castro, $10
MI -
OF - M.Stanton, $5 (+$10 for long-term contract)
OF - J.Heyward, $5
OF - D.Jennings, $5
OF
OF
UT
UT
P - S.Strasburg, $8
P - G.Gonzalez, $10
P - J.Zimmermann, $11
P -
P
P
P
P
P
P
FARM - B.Harper (WAS)
FARM - J.Montero (SEA)
FARM - J.Profar (TEX)

[MaudDib]

Did I miss it? What are the prices?

With out that info, I would take Moustakas. You need a 3B, so seems like a good move. Both have major questions marks and both have a lot of upside. Not sure which one is more likely to succeed so give me Moustakas.

[bostux]

Did I miss it? What are the prices?

With out that info, I would take Moustakas. You need a 3B, so seems like a good move. Both have major questions marks and both have a lot of upside. Not sure which one is more likely to succeed so give me Moustakas.

What he said. Taking price out of it I think looking at your roster Mous will help you out more. I see both players having the same upside with a ton of the same question marks.

[HOOTIE]

Goldschmidt, mainly because i think Moustakis is overrated.

[Rotowahoo]

Sorry, they're both $5. Do you think it's likely that their BA will be quite different?

[MadDog36]

Moose probably the second coming of Mark Reynolds (numbers wise w/o the Ks) I'd go with the player at the thinner position.