Phillips or kipnis

[Cwgibson]

5x5 h2h was offered kipnis/Norris for my Phillips/baker.

[zephyr]

Keeper league?

Kipinis is a young "poor man's" Phillips. If it's a single season scenario, I'd much rather have Phillips. if it's a keeper league, Kipinis could make sense. He's 6 years younger and is the better long-term option. But for the next year (or two?) I still see Phillips as the better option.

Norris is a personal fave...great K-potential and such. But...it'll be tricky to win much with that roster. Baker's alright...and I think undervalued...but definitely prefer Norris here.

Bottom line - If you can keep Kipinis, I lean toward that side of the deal. Otherwise, not sure Norris is enough to pursuade me.

Mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=441707

[MaudDib]

Keep Phillips. Kipnis has potential but that is all it right now and Norris and Baker are nice starters that could go either way this year. Phillips is easily the best player in the deal and the other side doesn't have enough in it to make up for that fact.

[Cwgibson]

Thanks not a keeper league, I was thinking I should keep Phillips.