I'm taking over a team in a league that has a 3 years limit on keepers (standard 5x5). My keepers will be Kemp, Tulo, Felix Hernandez, Konerko, Victorino, Cuddyer, Kimbrel, Luebke (I know Luebke sucks as a keeper but my only other choices are Bonifacio and Ubaldo Jimenez).
The top guys available in this draft are Pujols, Cano, Carlos Gonzalez, Prince Fielder, Jose Reyes, Roy Halladay, Justin Verlander. #3 is tricky because I feel like Pujols, Fielder, Cano, and Cargo can go in almost any order and my team already has a 1B (Konernko), a 2B (Cuddyer), and 2 or 3 OF (Kemp, Victorino, Cuddyer). How would you rank these guys considering my needs?