Huge trade in 14 team keeper [WHIR]

[baseballfan89]

I wouldn't do this trade.. Kemp is better than A Gon imo, and i like players that possess power and speed, and Kemp has both! Also, Felix might be slightly better than Weaver but Weavers playing on a perennial championship club! And yes he has Pujols now aswell.

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=441037

[HOOTIE]

Agreed. Also, Felix has that horrible offense behind him and struggles majorly to get W's. I don't think Weaver will have quite as much trouble in that category.

(And yes, I know chasing W's usually isn't a great idea, but when the talent is that close, it matters)

Last 3 years
Weaver 47 wins
Felix 46 wins

And during none of those three years did Weaver have Pujols' huge bat helping provide run support for him. Felix is clearly the better overall pitcher, but he's just saddled with that horrible Seattle lumber.

Great they added Pujols.
Last 3 years
Angels 2,231 runs
Mariners 1,709 runs
Angels scored 522 more runs, yet Weaver won 1 more game.
Everyone forgets Carp, Ackely, Montero, Smoak are all improving and pre-peak.
The only reason i debate this is you can't chase wins.
Felix is amazing.

[Kimbos Beard]

I wouldn't do this. I like Felix more than Weaver, but you already have an elite 1B and Kemp is a notch above Gonzalez so it doesn't seem to make any sense for your roster to do this.

[Broncmet724]

I think I'd keep Kemp, since you'd need to put A Gon in your UT spot