Bruce vs. McCutcheon Views * WHIR *

[Nighttrain]

You have to go McCuthen over Bruce. Bruce had 1 good month last year that padded his stats, maybe it was 6 weeks

viewtopic.php?t=440926

[Kimbos Beard]

I want McCutch all the way. It's not even close.

It's close.
I love both, but lean AM.
Bruce has 35+ hr power.

Bruce has 35+ hr power, theres no question about that, but he's going to bat in the .255 range and steal maybe 7-8 bases.

I view McCutch as a guy that will hit 25 Hr's and steal 25 bags while batting in the .280 range.

RBI's and Runs will probably be close between the two. SO I am not sure why you would want Bruce over McCutch.

[HOOTIE]

I want McCutch all the way. It's not even close.

It's close.
I love both, but lean AM.
Bruce has 35+ hr power.

Bruce has 35+ hr power, theres no question about that, but he's going to bat in the .255 range and steal maybe 7-8 bases.

I view McCutch as a guy that will hit 25 Hr's and steal 25 bags while batting in the .280 range.

RBI's and Runs will probably be close between the two. SO I am not sure why you would want Bruce over McCutch.

I said i prefer AM, but it's close imo.
Bruce hit .308 in the minors. He's not a .250 hitter.
Bruce win win hrs and rbis easily. And i'm betting the BA is less then 20 points.

[Kimbos Beard]

It's close.
I love both, but lean AM.
Bruce has 35+ hr power.

Bruce has 35+ hr power, theres no question about that, but he's going to bat in the .255 range and steal maybe 7-8 bases.

I view McCutch as a guy that will hit 25 Hr's and steal 25 bags while batting in the .280 range.

RBI's and Runs will probably be close between the two. SO I am not sure why you would want Bruce over McCutch.

I said i prefer AM, but it's close imo.
Bruce hit .308 in the minors. He's not a .250 hitter.
Bruce win win hrs and rbis easily. And i'm betting the BA is less then 20 points.

Fair enough, I usually agree with alot of your opinions, so its cool.

Although, I will say Bruce has 500 major league games and about 1900 AB's and is a .256 hitter, I would not expect anything more than .255 from Bruce at this point.

[CadensDad]

Another vote for McCutchen