Last Offensive Keeper

[andrewkeefe]

5x5 roto vanilla. Already keeping Bruce (7) and Bourn (8).

I have:

Beltre (2)
Stubbs (16)
Beltran (27)

Who do I keep? Beltre obviously best player- but not a value at 2, and I could probably get him back. Beltran a bargain at 27? Stubbs great skill set at 16?

You tell me.

[HOOTIE]

Stubbs, just because i think he's better then what he showed last year.

[lane_anasazi2]

I like Stubbs as well. Very dangerous power/speed combination, capable of putting up a monster season but playing time, K rate makes him super volatile.

[Broncmet724]

I like Beltran for a \/alue at 27. You know he'll miss time but when he plays he'll be good

[Kimbos Beard]

I grudgingly say Stubbs. I like Beltran and he has very good value in the 27th but in a keeper its hard to hold onto Beltran with his age and injury history.

Stubbs offers a nasty combo of power and speed which I like, but you are already keeping Bruce, which means 2 out of your 3 keepers will likely hit below .260. So do it, but be prepared to address BA on your team.

[kidsilk]

Stubbs, he is just showing us what he can do.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=440846

[kslates]

I grudgingly say Stubbs. I like Beltran and he has very good value in the 27th but in a keeper its hard to hold onto Beltran with his age and injury history.

This is exactly what I was going to say

help me?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=440848

[handyman01]

I grudgingly say Stubbs. I like Beltran and he has very good value in the 27th but in a keeper its hard to hold onto Beltran with his age and injury history.

Stubbs offers a nasty combo of power and speed which I like, but you are already keeping Bruce, which means 2 out of your 3 keepers will likely hit below .260. So do it, but be prepared to address BA on your team.

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd go with Beltran. He's the best value for the rounds IMO. If you like Stubbs you should be able to get him back in the draft.

[MadDog36]

Beltran is best value here, take him. He's got one more topish year left in him and besides you can rock the house with that. Stubbs is a 25/20 guy but with an abysmal BA, solid value too, but you already have Bruce so take Beltran. He'll hit 290/29/106 I have a feeling.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=440861&p=3483402#p3483394