In your situation, I would go with Verlander. I'm biased, with being a Tiger fan, but with that lineup, I can see him getting 20 wins, and he's a sure lock for 200+ Ks every season. I like Bautista and Lawrie for you, also.
Dwight Schrute: Michael, you forgot to mention the herpes.
Michael Scott: It didn't come out organically.