Trade Cano for Reyes / Greinke?

[wags87]

I've been offered Reyes and Greinke for Cano.

Again, four team keeper league. I love Cano, but that's a pretty solid offer. Leaves me with Reyes, Lincecum, Greinke as keepers, and then a choice between Pablo Sandoval and Adrian Beltre. Arguably I'd try to move one of them or both as a package for a top tier keeper... APpreciate the insight as always.

C- Pierzynski
1b - Ryan Howard
2b - R Cano
3b - Pablo Sandoval and Adrian Beltre
SS - JJ Hardy
OF - Melky Cabrera
OF - Shane Victorino
OF - BJ Upton
UTIL - Micheal Bourn
UTIL - Jeter
Bench: Daniel Murphy, Mark Reynolds

P- U Jimenez
P- Colby Lewis
SP - Roy Oswalt
SP - Tim Lincecum
SP -James Shields
RP - Papelbon and Brian Wilson
Bench: Erik Bedard, Bartolo Colon

[GiantsFan14]

no way to i do this. lincecum shouldn't even be a keeper over pablo or beltre so you'd pretty much be dealing cano for reyes with an upgrade from lincecum to greinke. there's no reason you should be dealing quality for quantity when you're only keeping 4 players. studs are just too valuable.

[kaiser]

I can understand why you would consider this, but I also believe that you should stand pat with Cano. I don't completely trust Reyes to stay healthy, and his performance is the key to whether this deal has value for you or not. Too much chance.

[kidsilk]

I agree, keep Cano.


please help

viewtopic.php?t=440760

[Kimbos Beard]

Keep Cano and keep try to move Beltre of Pablo if you can get equal value.

[jjkkwii222]

thanks a lot.

[MadDog36]

Counter him Sandoval + Lince for his Reyes + Greinke see what he will do.
Then you'd keep:
2b R Cano
3b - Adrian Beltre
SS - Reyes
SP - Greinke

[Broncmet724]

4 team keeper, or 4 keepers a team? with the roster I assume 4 keepers. No I wouldn't do the trade

[MaudDib]

Counter him Sandoval + Lince for his Reyes + Greinke see what he will do.
Then you'd keep:
2b R Cano
3b - Adrian Beltre
SS - Reyes
SP - Greinke

I like this. How many teams though? Not really four is it?