Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

by **amarlls** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 1:43 pm

Ok I am in a 3rd year keeper league $260 Roster space for 29 players. 5x5 Roto. We have $300 total space throughout the year to open up more trading. Which 5 should I keep

Carl Crawford $54
Billy Butler $23
Mike Moustakas $5 ***
Dee Gordon $5
Gaby Sanchez $10 ***
Andre Ethier $34
Alex Gordon $5
Seth Smith $5
Jeff Fraceour $5
Grady Sizemore $10
Mike Trout $5 ***
Alberto Callaspo $5

Daniel Hudson $10***
Michael Pineda $5***
Tim Stauffer $5
Adam Wainwright $5 ***
Phillip Humber $5
Aroldis Chapman $5 ***

by **HOOTIE** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 1:46 pm

Carl Crawford $54
Billy Butler $23
Mike Moustakas $5 *** ;-D

Dee Gordon $5
Gaby Sanchez $10 ***
Andre Ethier $34
Alex Gordon $5 ;-D

Seth Smith $5
Jeff Fraceour $5
Grady Sizemore $10
Mike Trout $5 ***
Alberto Callaspo $5

Daniel Hudson $10*** ;-D

Michael Pineda $5*** ;-D

Tim Stauffer $5
Adam Wainwright $5 *** ;-D

Phillip Humber $5
Aroldis Chapman $5 ***

by **GiantsFan14** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 1:58 pm

amarlls wrote:Ok I am in a 3rd year keeper league $260 Roster space for 29 players. 5x5 Roto. We have $300 total space throughout the year to open up more trading. Which 5 should I keep

Carl Crawford $54
Billy Butler $23
Mike Moustakas $5 ***
Dee Gordon $5
Gaby Sanchez $10 ***
Andre Ethier $34
Alex Gordon $5
Seth Smith $5
Jeff Fraceour $5
Grady Sizemore $10
Mike Trout $5 ***
Alberto Callaspo $5

Daniel Hudson $10***
Michael Pineda $5***
Tim Stauffer $5
Adam Wainwright $5 ***
Phillip Humber $5
Aroldis Chapman $5 ***

by **raiders_umpire** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 3:02 pm

Alex Gordon $5
Mike Trout $5 ***

Daniel Hudson $10***
Michael Pineda $5***
Adam Wainwright $5 ***

by **Pogotheostrich** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 3:19 pm

Alex Gordon $5
Mike Trout $5 ***
Daniel Hudson $10***
Michael Pineda $5***
Adam Wainwright $5 ***

by **wheels** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 3:26 pm

What do the ***'s represent?

I would keep A Gordon, Trout, Wainwright, Pineda and Hudson.

please help...viewtopic.php?t=440675

by **amarlls** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 3:30 pm

Oh sorry, I put those but didnt emphasize what they meant. Those were the guys I was leaning towards. I like the guys that all of you mentioned just at a cross between Moustkas and Trout as OF is thick position and 3B is pretty tight so its a hard choice. But I do have a solid pitching staff locked in at least for now

by **Element** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 3:32 pm

raiders_umpire wrote:Alex Gordon $5
Mike Trout $5 ***

Daniel Hudson $10***
Michael Pineda $5***
Adam Wainwright $5 ***

I think that I like this the best depending upon what happens to the dollar values moving forward. If they increase $5+ each season I may lean toward letting Trout walk and keeping Moustakas. I would certainly attempt to re-acquire Trout through the draft.

by **wheels** » Wed Mar 07, 2012 4:04 pm

Fair point, but with both at $5 I still like Trout over Moustakas, even with position scarcity. Assuming you use standard 5X5 hitting cats, Trout should give you more R, SB & BA and Moustakis should give you more RBI & HR. It's close and I don't think you can go too wrong either way, but Trout at 20 years old is as ML ready as Moustakas is at 23.

please help...viewtopic.php?t=440675