King Felix for Josh Hamilton? WHIR

[BronXBombers51]

12 teams - Rotisserie - 6x6 (normal + OPS & Losses)

Must keep between 4 and 8 players. Here's my keepers as of now.

C-
1B- Miguel Cabrera
2B- Ian Kinsler
3B- Pablo Sandoval
SS- Troy Tulowitzki
OF- Adam Jones
OF-
OF-
Utl-
Utl-

SP- Felix Hernandez
SP- CC Sabathia
RP-
RP-
P- Matt Cain
P-
P-
P-

Was offered Josh Hamilton for Felix Hernandez (he might want a late draft pick too.) I can afford to lose a SP and can use an OF. Worth it?

[Broncmet724]

It's not a bad deal, about a $4 difference with similar but not exactly the same stats in another league. Make sure you get a decent backup with all the time he's sure to miss

[HOOTIE]

In a keeper no.
I would do it for Cain or CC though.

[MadDog36]

Yes you can afford to lose King Felix, but I wouldn't give him up. Counter his offer CC for Hamilton. I wouldn't want to give up a young ace like Felix for an older but productive OF. OF value takes a bit of a hit since you only start 3 and you use a bit of pitching.

[kidsilk]

Agree with MadDog on this one. Don't trade Felix, but I would do CC for Hamilton.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=440732

[BronXBombers51]

He has Andrew McCutchen too, who I prefer over Hamilton. Would you give Felix for him? (Don't know if he'd accept, just speculating.) Or stick with Felix no matter what and only shop CC/Cain?

[HOOTIE]

He has Andrew McCutchen too, who I prefer over Hamilton. Would you give Felix for him? (Don't know if he'd accept, just speculating.) Or stick with Felix no matter what and only shop CC/Cain?

I love AM, but i shop CC or Cain.
Felix is your 3rd best player.

[GiantsFan14]

He has Andrew McCutchen too, who I prefer over Hamilton. Would you give Felix for him? (Don't know if he'd accept, just speculating.) Or stick with Felix no matter what and only shop CC/Cain?

I'd do either trade.

[Element]

He has Andrew McCutchen too, who I prefer over Hamilton. Would you give Felix for him? (Don't know if he'd accept, just speculating.) Or stick with Felix no matter what and only shop CC/Cain?

I'd do either trade.

I agree. You're set at SP and adding a bat of equal or greater value.

[kslates]

He has Andrew McCutchen too, who I prefer over Hamilton. Would you give Felix for him? (Don't know if he'd accept, just speculating.) Or stick with Felix no matter what and only shop CC/Cain?

I'd take Felix over both hitters but both hitters over CC/Cain


Help me?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=440746