Lincecum or Gallardo in NL Only League?(WHIR)

[MadDog36]

OF-Bourn(24)
OF-CarGo(42)
U-R.Roberts(1)

P-David Hernandez(1)
P-Daniel Hudson(15)
P-Latos(21)
P-Lincecum(33)
P-Leubke(1)
BN-Medlen(1)

I'd keep these 9.
Pass

[kidsilk]

Just got a me offer. His Carlos beltran (12) and jimmy rollins(23) for my Alex Gonzalez and Daniel Hudson. I pull the trigger on this one don't ya think?

[Nighttrain]

Gallardo. Lincecum is better but not $12 better

[cordscords]

Just got a me offer. His Carlos beltran (12) and jimmy rollins(23) for my Alex Gonzalez and Daniel Hudson. I pull the trigger on this one don't ya think?

[curl]

Just got a me offer. His Carlos beltran (12) and jimmy rollins(23) for my Alex Gonzalez and Daniel Hudson. I pull the trigger on this one don't ya think?

The only concern I'd personally have with a deal like this is that the core of the team you're going to be keeping are all on the young side and will be hitting their primes over the next several seasons, while Beltran and Rollins are on the opposite side of that. It certainly helps you for this next season, but I could easily see you keeping neither player heading into 2013. I guess in the end, for me, it'd come down to how close you really were to the teams that finished above you.

[kidsilk]

Any other opinions on the new Rollins deal? Please help, any help is appreciated. Thanks and leave your links!

[MadDog36]

Beltran is a bit underrated not OVERrated. He is still valuable and useful, just with an injury risk. Good deal for you. Rollins I'm not sure on but a definite upgrade over A-Whiff

[kidsilk]

Hey MadDog, what do you think about the Bourn and Holliday deal I was offered too? So you are saying do the Rollins deal?

[kidsilk]

Just to clarify this thread for those of you who are new to it we are down to two trades:

Holliday and Wolf for Lilly and Bourn

and

Rollins and Beltran for D. Hudson and Alex Gonzalez

What to do?

[jasonpm311]

I'd go with Lincecum, assuming you are getting rid of Ubaldo. Thanks for your help on my Gallardo vs. Lester question!

viewtopic.php?t=440272