Lincecum or Gallardo in NL Only League?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

NL only, 6x6, holds and ops, 13 team, roto style, keeper league, auction, 260 dollar cap. Prices of players stays the same each year.

I have Timmy at 33 bucks and would definitely be a keeper and I have been offered Gallardo at 20 bucks in a trade. Who would you rather have at this point and at these salaries?

[dominodoug]

I gotta go with Gallardo at $20.

[cordscords]

I would like to see the whole team, how much $ you have, and the top available players in the draft before I can comment.

[Hawkeye1]

[quote="cordscords"]I would like to see the whole team, how much $ you have, and the top available players in the draft before I can comment.[/quote]

I have to agree with this sentiment. Without additional info, it's hard to say. However, even with the price difference, I like Timmy.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=440227

[kidsilk]

My Roster: (Haven't picked my keepers yet), I came in fourth last season with this roster.

C-Hanigan(2)
C-Navarro(1)
1B-Lee(1)
2B-Barney(1)
3B-McGehee(20)
SS-Gonzalez(6)
MI-DeWitt(1)
CI-Wood(1)
OF-Bourn(24)
OF-CarGo(42)
OF-Harris(1)
OF-Hawpe(4)
U-R.Roberts(1)
U-Morgan(13)

P-Billingsley(15)
P-Gorzo(1)
P-David Hernandez(1)
P-Daniel Hudson(15)
P-Ubaldo(26)
P-Latos(21)
P-Lincecum(33)
P-Lilly(12)
P-Leubke(1)
BN-Cashner(1)
BN-Medlen(1)
BN-Oswalt(19)
BN-Padilla(1)
BN-Broxton(16)
BN-Kuo(9)

[cordscords]

How many players can you keep?

[kidsilk]

You can keep up to 10 but don't have to keep anyone.

[kidsilk]

Nevermind, the dipshit just trade Gallardo for Daniel Murphy!

Thanks for your help so far though.

[cordscords]

I'm thinking keep Bourn, CarGo, Hudson, Latos, Lincecum and Leubke. $121 leaving you to fill 23 spots. I don't think you have to make the deal considering the talent pool that will get sent back, and I definitely prefer Lincecum straight up. If you can counter offer for a productive hitter that can save you $8-$10 that might be worth it.

EDIT- lol. Terrible deal for them. I would make the same suggestion though. Shop Timmy around and see if you can get a good offer.

[germani40]

I am a big Lincecum fan so I would have taken him over Gallardo