C Lucroy, Jonathan (C MIL) C · U ACT C Avila, Alex (C DET) C · U ACT 1B Santana, Carlos (C CLE) 1B · C · CI · U ACT 2B Johnson, Kelly (2B TOR) 2B · MI · U ACT 3B Bautista, Jose (OF TOR) 3B · CI · OF · U ACT SS Jeter, Derek (SS NYY) MI · SS · U ACT MI Escobar, Yunel (SS TOR) MI · SS · U ACT CI Rodriguez, Alex (3B NYY) 3B · CI · U ACT OF Jones, Adam (OF BAL) OF · U ACT OF Upton, Justin (OF ARI) OF · U ACT OF Francoeur, Jeff (OF KC) OF · U ACT OF Cabrera, Melky (OF SF) OF · U ACT OF Tabata, Jose (OF PIT) OF · U ACT U Young, Michael (3B TEX) 1B · 3B · CI · U ACT P Carpenter, Chris (P STL) P ACT P Pineda, Michael (P NYY) P ACT P Wilson, Brian (P SF) P ACT P Kimbrel, Craig (P ATL) P ACT P Nathan, Joe (P TEX) P ACT P Hellickson, Jeremy (P TB) P ACT P Strasburg, Stephen (P WAS) P ACT P Darvish, Yu (P TEX) P ACT P Romero, Ricky (P TOR) P ACT RES Fister, Doug (P DET) P ACT RES Headley, Chase (3B SD) 3B · CI · U ACT RES Willingham, Josh (OF MIN) OF · U ACT RES Boesch, Brennan (OF DET) OF · U ACT RES Kuroda, Hiroki (P NYY) P ACT RES Teheran, Julio (P ATL)
"They give you a round bat and they throw you a round ball. And they tell you to hit it square."-Willie Stargell
Since I don't know the league parameters (roto, H2H, 5x5?), nor do I know if its auction/draft (assuming the latter), I'd say you did well on the pitching side. That should carry you. I am not enamored with your OF outside of Upton. I also dislike 2B immensely. Perhaps you can trade pitching depth, but this team looks solid and should compete.
Baseball is a game where a curve is an optical illusion, a screwball can be a pitch or a person, stealing is legal and you can spit anywhere you like except in the umpire's eye or on the ball. ~Jim Murray
Like the guy above said, hard to evaluate since the league info and the pick you had aren't posted. The back end of your OF and 2B are your weaknesses. Your OFs outside of Upton are unproven outside of last year. I don't know if you trust them enough to keep them based on last year, but its something to consider. Your pitching is deep. Good team overall, could be better with a few tweaks.