Young and Sabathia for Halladay? (WHIR)

[KosherK]

I'm in a keeper league and I've been offered Halladay for Michael Young and C.C. Sabathia

It's a points league and Halladay tends to get about 100pts more than C.C. year over year - my only concern here is that in Yahoo Young gets 1B, 2B & 3B eligibility so he's a rock across several positions - am I giving up too much for Halliday here.

As a note if I give up Young my other keeper would shit to either Desmond Jennings of Zach Greinke

[MashinSpuds]

Yep, if you find that Halladay earns more than CC, then I would do the trade given your keeper replacements. Position eligibility is wonderful and all, but it shouldn't force your hand too much when it comes to talent. Plus, Halladay/Jennings is a better keeper duo than CC/Young anyway.

Make the trade.

[joeyg2323]

i wouldnt make the trade giving up to much with young in the deal.


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=439561

[GiantsFan14]

Halladay + Greinke > Sabathia + Young

nice trade for you.

[Broncmet724]

I'd do the trade.

[silverZ]

Halladay + Greinke >>>>>>>> Sabathia + Young

nice trade for you.

Fixed that for you