ichiro vs. andruw jones

[perlick29]

Who would you rather have of these two studs?
I just proposed a trade that would get me Ichiro for Andruw straight-up. So I need some feedback, who would you rather have factoring in a standard 5X5 roto league?

[Ry-Guy]

ICHIRO! Hands down. He's better in every category except for HRs and RBI, and you can find those everywhere.

[rayt132]

this just depends what you need more,
power - Jones or speed - Ichiro

[wilsonfuller]

I'd rather trade someone less awesome for Crawford than trade Andruw for Ichiro, and Crawford will steal 20 more bases!