Keeper: Lincecum or Mike Stanton

[toof90]

Should I keep Tim Lincecum and give up my 2nd round pick, or should I keep Mike Stanton and give up my 7th round pick?

My other keepers are
Miguel Cabrera (Round 1)
Justin Upton (Round 4)
Dan Haren (Round 5)

we get to keep 4
Its a 12 team leauge

[joeyg2323]

thats tough, who else are you keeping? do you want 15 wins and 200ks or 40 hr and 100 rbis? what is more of a need for your team right now.

[toof90]

thats tough, who else are you keeping? do you want 15 wins and 200ks or 40 hr and 100 rbis? what is more of a need for your team right now.

So far Ive kept
Miguel Cabrera (Round 1)
Justin Upton (Round 4)
Dan Haren (Round 5)

4 keepers allowed

[joeyg2323]

id keep lincecum over haren and keep stanton. Thats the best 4 i can think of


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=439779

[KempCamp]

id keep lincecum over haren and keep stanton. Thats the best 4 i can think of


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=439779

i agree with this. if this is not an option then i go with stanton because of draft round difference and the fact that i usually always lean bat over arm when close in selecting keepers. even a lincecum arm. but i agree with letting haren go and ponying up that 2nd to keep lincecum as well as stanton. those 4 keepers would be DIRTY!

viewtopic.php?t=439749

[raiders_umpire]

Stanton easily over Lincecum

[GiantsFan14]

Stanton easily over Lincecum

ya, even without the round discrepancy it's stanton. with it and it's not close.

[LARS929]

I agree with the guy who said keep Lincecum and Stanton and throw back Haren.

If you can't do that, then keep Stanton over Lincecum by a MILE, they are comparable without the picks involved. But add in the picks and you shouldn't even think twice.

[Fenris-77]

Stanton easily over Lincecum

ya, even without the round discrepancy it's stanton. with it and it's not close.

Factually correct.

[lostraven]

I'm also on the "keep Lincecum and Stanton" boat.