Which would you rather have?

[ichirosan]

I'm basically choosing between these in my 20 man 6x6 (Holds and Ops) Dynasty

Option A:
Ian Desmond, Trevor Cahill and some bum RP (Steve Cishek, for example)

Option B:
Zack Cozart, Roy Oswalt and a better RP (but not a closer, Koji Uehara-Francisco Cordero type)

[fast dogs]

Oswalt is 1 tweak from retirement, I'd take the Cahill side

[GiantsFan14]

B for me. at least when oswalt is pitching he won't be terrible.

[jtsandwich]

i would have to go with B, Cahill does not impress me after 1 decent yr, 2 back.

[Fenris-77]

B for me. at least when oswalt is pitching he won't be terrible.

This.

[MadDog36]

Zack Cozart, Roy Oswalt, David Robertson/EOF/Casilla

[ichirosan]

Went with Cahill last night because I was afraid Oswalt ended up doing... well, what he ended up doing.

The difference between the RPs was because draft picks were involved, so I hope I don't end up regretting that part of the deal.