Definitely take Aramis Ramirez over Dmitri Young.
In that lineup with Sosa, Alou, and Derek Lee, Aramis can hit over 30 HRs and drive in 100 runs.
Dmitri has always been an injury concern and he won't repeat his 2003 season. Detroit offers him no protection in the lineup and he won't have many guys to drive in.
Aramis Ramirez should go .285/31 HRs/102 RBI
Dmitri Young will do .295/24 HRs/90RBI
Check out www.hardcorefantasybaseball.com