Elvis, Fielder, Tulo, Lawrie

[texastattoo87972]

Hey all,
In a 16 team, 9 keeper league, head-to-head each category:
Hitting----R, RBIs, 1Bs, 2Bs, 3Bs, HRS, AVG, Steals
Pitching----ERA, WHIP, W, L, Ks, Saves

My keepers right now are:
Tulo
Longo
J. Upton
Shane Vic
Brett Lawrie
Ike Davis

Kershaw
Dan Hudson
Strasborg

I was offered this trade:
My Tulo, My Lawrie for Prince Fielder and Elvis Andrus and his 10 round pick (which would be the 1 overall pick after the keepers, and no we do not HAVE to keep 9.)

Would you pull the trigger on this trade?

[rockiesnbuffs]

I think the trade suits your teams needs very well. You are gaining solid consistent production from 2 of the most healthy players in the game. You also get the top available pick in the draft. You are giving up some potential - but i think lawrie is overrated and tulo has yet to play a full season while prince and andrus have not had any substantial injuries.

[sfjb]

I don't think I make that trade. Tulo's replacement value at a thin position is hard to beat. I think Ike will have a good year, so you're covered there. Lawrie is a 20/20 candidate which is hard to beat at 3B. so you look down 140 players or so and is that player a deal maker? Probably not. I'd pass.

[Element]

Tulo > Prince
Lawrie > Andrus

That player you would be getting with that 1st pick would need to be excellent. With this many keepers, I don't see it happening. Stay put.

[rotoquest]

Tulo > Prince
Lawrie > Andrus

That player you would be getting with that 1st pick would need to be excellent. With this many keepers, I don't see it happening. Stay put.

+1 with this.

[bigh0rt]

No.

[MadDog36]

Tulo
Longo
J. Upton
Shane Vic
Brett Lawrie
Ike Davis
Kershaw
Dan Hudson
Strasburg

Do you have another batter you can keep instead of Huddy? Hitters are EASILY more valuable....and ptiching can ALWAYS be had.....even in a deep league.