The SLG% def favors Uggla and puts him above Andrus, but I believe Andrus has the ability to land you at least 3 of the 7 stat cats, SB, OBP and Runs, and possibly AVG. Its close, but I think Uggla has the edge.
For all the categories listed, I have to go with Alex Gordon. He isn't stellar in any of those categories, but he won't hurt you in any and he will produce the most across the board in them. I like what Seitzer did with his swing last year, and I think at 28 he can repeat the success. Good Luck.