id say yes, u have 3 catchers as it is. you certainly dont need that many. david wright is a potential 30 hr 20 sb 100 rbi/100 runs .300 caliber. granted thats a stretch but with the fences moving in and ike/duda to protect him alittle i think hell have a solid year. mauer and montero arent guarentees to be great hitters by any means. weiters is actually my favorite of the 3 and u get to keep him.
David Wright and Dustin Ackley. Yes 3b would make a huge hole on your team but this deal solidifies your offense. You'd still have a stud #1 catcher and a #2 catcher you can get (maybe Lucroy Mesoraco, Ramos, Molina) would be had in the draft.
The best there is, the best there was, and the best there ever will be!