In a 10 team, 5x5 roto league, 5 keepers. No keeper rules...just pick 5 then start the snake draft in inverse order of finish. I won the league last year so I have the 10th pick, 11th, etc.
Keeping Votto, Mig Cabrera, and Kemp.
Debating between the following for my last two spots.
Just a note, pitching is usually available in the draft in this league, so I'm leaning toward offense, and I'm usually not one to keep a closer, but Kimbrel is one I'd consider.