14 team league, 3 keepers per year, 6x6 roto with OPS and Holds
I have been offered Carlos Santana and an 11th round pick(we are currently in the 9th round) for MY Utley and J. Montero. With my 11th pick I could pick up a MI that I need, esp after losing Utley or a solid SP like Chacin, Baker, Fister, Lewis, Ogando, McCarthy etc. Is Santana worth this?
I personally don't think that this deal really helps that much. Montero is a solid option. You'd be giving up two solid fantasy contributors. Your team looks better with these guys IMO. Would need to know who you'd have at 2B?
Tough call. I think I would stay with Utley and J. Montero. I think Santana is better than Montero is 2012, but I think they are even in 2013 and Montero has more long-term upside after that. I don't think Utley returns to his full glory days, but I think he is being undervalued for 2012. I don't think it's a matter of skill, just a matter of health. If he plays 150+ games, he could easily put up .280/90/20/90/15 or better. That's a lot of production from the 2B spot. That would be hard to replace. I think the drop off at 2B for you would be MORE than the gain you would get at C from Montero to Santana. Plus, your SP's are looking ok, so I don't think targeting SP in the 11th round is worth the trade.
ps - I don't like those options at 2B. I think that is why the other manager has been so aggressive trying to target Utley. He is trying to pick him up when his value is low and trying to avoid the other 2B options you listed.
Love Donnie Baseball. Favorite player of all-time.
Last edited by dmbpanic on Sun Feb 12, 2012 2:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I have a tough time believing your team is better with the weak middle; what did Santana hit last year 240? you've already got Reynolds holding you down there and your middles won't help that either. Unless its a clear win I say don't trade, I'm not even sure its a win at all.Keep Utley
When asking for roster advice in these pages, remember there are thousands of different sets of league rules & many different active roster settings. If you want the best replies, be sure to include your leagues particulars in the original post
fast dogs wrote:I have a tough time believing your team is better with the weak middle; what did Santana hit last year 240? you've already got Reynolds holding you down there and your middles won't help that either. Unless its a clear win I say don't trade, I'm not even sure its a win at all.Keep Utley
Agree with this above. Stand pat with Utely and Montero. Tough to say that as I'm a really high on Santana, but the loss of production from Utely is too much to swallow. Can you get something else other than 11th round?