Keeper Help

[lotsofluck]

I'm new here and would appreciate keeper help
16 team Yahoo H2H, finished 15th last year
min 8 keepers, max 10
Pitching Stats: IP, W, L, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, QS
Hitting Stats: 1B, HR, R, RBI, SB, BB, K, AVG, OPS, XBH
Keeping: Votto, C. Lee, Stubbs, Gallardo, Weaver, D. Hudson, Lawrie
Moustakas, Tabata, Minor are 3 guys I have. Please tell me which one of these guys would you keep.

Thanks

[GiantsFan14]

welcome to the cafe!

Do you give up picks for each player you keep? If not, then I see no problem with keeping all three of them in a 16 team league. If yes, then I'd probably only keep Tabata.

[lilfrier]

I agree that if you're not giving up picks to keep them, keep all 3. They all hold enough value to be worth more than whatever bottom-of-the-barrel guy you'll snag in a final round.

[lotsofluck]

The penalty is a draft pick, that's why I was leaning toward one of them. Thank you for your replys

[lotsofluck]

I just got home so the round that they were drafted
Votto(1st), Lee(2nd), Stubbs (4th), Gallardo (5th), Weaver (6th), D. Hudson (9th), Lawrie (undrafted, automatically slots into 25th round pick)
V- Mart was my 3rd rounder so I can't keep him
So:
Tabata: 8th
Moustakas: 18th
Minor: 20th
Thanks again

[GiantsFan14]

I would keep Moustakas and Minor. They're worth 18 and 20th round picks, especially in in a 16 team league.

[mpoland92]

if the penalty is a draft pck I would keep all 3 if it was my team, odds are you wouldnt find someone like them when the drat starts and they would prolly be helping your competition.... but you got a good list of keepers no doubt..... good luck!!!

help me out... viewtopic.php?t=439133

[wilhouse]

I argee in a 16 team league the talent pool is thin as it is, so keeping who ever you can would be best.

[Fenris-77]

I would keep Moustakas and Minor. They're worth 18 and 20th round picks, especially in in a 16 team league.

This is factually correct.

[mikekim2121]

I think you should keep all 10. The only one I'm hesitant about is Tabata for an 8th round pick, but in such a deep league, that might not be so bad. Your pitching is solid so work on your hitting in the draft.