Doing my projections using Fangraphs....I have come up with the following comparison...keeping in mind this isn't a standard fantasy league, but a simulation league where everything counts (defense, etc) the projected WAR for 2012 (according to my projections, and WAR does include a projected UZR defensive score) for each guy:
Kemp - 6.1
McCutchen - 5.8
Pujols - 5.5
Tex - 5.5
I have Kemp at .876 OPS, 40 2B, 28 HR, 36 SB
McCutchen at .816 OPS, 41 2B, 18 HR, 36 SB
Pujols at .924 OPS, 35 2B, 38 HR, 5 SB
Tex at .876 OPS, 35 2B, 33 HR, 4 SB
I try to be "safe" with my projections...so I'm not sure if I've lowballed McCutchen on power or not...but I don't see him hitting more than about 23 HR or so while Kemp could be more up around 35 or so....
In the game (at Scoresheet.com)...the defensive scores have McCutchen just a tick above Kemp, and Pujols is a little better than Tex.